Everybody Is Wrong About Jane Doe
The hosts and Cat argue the Cornell fraternity case is being driven by online mass hysteria, with Jane Doe's early accounts describing consensual if regretted activity, and that it reflects a push for women's liberty without responsibility.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 0:28
Jane Doe's story has been reframed: early accounts described consensual activity, and the rape claim rests on her being too drunk to consent
Cat says Jane Doe's report, made about three weeks after the night, came with a full narrative that “legally sounded like a lot of really sloppy, unpleasant, but consensual sexual activity and drug use.” Two years later she hasn't changed the story but now argues her heavy drinking on arrival meant she could not consent to anything after. That is the basis for her civil suit, and the hosts note it is one possible interpretation versus a feminist one.
- ▶ 2:30
The public narrative about the seven men is fabricated, and the details of the case don't support the outrage
The host says he looked at the details after seeing calls for castration and found they don't match what is being claimed. He describes the night as a series of consensual pairings and threesomes, with three of the seven not participating by her own admission. He says viral posts are complete fabrications and compares the moment to 2017. This time he refuses to stay on the sidelines while lives are potentially ruined.
- ▶ 6:03
The legal case is sloppy: the suit blames others for not protecting her from her own drinking, and a wrong man was served
Cat notes the suit targets all seven men, the fraternity, her sorority, Cornell and a bar, on the theory that they failed to protect her from herself. The lawsuit was first served on a random man with the same name as a defendant. His name and address leaked and his family was harassed. The host expects a trial, since the accused have little way to recover otherwise.
- ▶ 9:34
Sex positivity pushes young people into extreme sexual experiences, and consent doesn't remove the emotional consequences
Cat argues that millennial feminism's drive to destigmatize sex has made “Olympic elite athlete level” activity feel expected at the start of sexual life. Young people don't realize there may be an emotional component, which they can't gauge until they've been out there. Jane Doe's text said she thought people were more open to this kind of sex now. Cat also sees self-narrativizing, where people cared more about the story they could tell than about the acts.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.