Liaquat Ahamed on Financial Crises, Gold, and the Lessons of 1873
Ahamed argues the 1873 crisis was a deflationary shock whose lasting damage was distributional and political, driven by Bismarck's destruction of bimetallism, with parallels to later crises, debt restructuring and bubbles.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 1:02
1873 was less a depression than a 'First Great Deflation' whose damage was political and distributional
Liaquat says the crisis did not plunge the world into a great depression the way the 1920s–30s did. Growth stayed resilient because prices and nominal wages were flexible. The harm came from distribution: populism in the US, renewed protectionism in Europe, a retreat from liberal ideas and revived imperialism after Britain invaded Egypt. He says a better title would have been “The First Great Deflation.”
- ▶ 6:45
The 1873 downturn broke Reconstruction by reviving the Democrats, a line that runs to Jim Crow
Liaquat notes the Republicans looked set to dominate American politics, holding the presidency and both houses. The crisis and the monetary decisions that followed set them back. The Democrats returned in the 1874 congressional election and nearly won in 1876, which Liaquat says they arguably did, losing only through a backroom deal. That ended Reconstruction, and he says it is “not hard to trace a line” to Jim Crow.
- ▶ 7:59
Boom-bust railroad builders were heroes, but the era's growth was unstable, not steady
Tyler argues loose credit and flexible prices produced great infrastructure. Liaquat agrees the three railroad booms and busts left a “fantastic transportation system” and the builders were heroes. He rejects calling the era steady: half of 1873–1896 was classified as recessionary. He also doubts flexible wages could be restored, since he does not think it is politically feasible.
- ▶ 11:19
Gladstone's Egyptian bonds show how imperial power set the price of sovereign debt
Gladstone put 40 percent of his net worth into Egyptian bonds yielding 12 to 14 percent, then Britain invaded and insisted on repayment near par. Turkey, strategically needed as a bulwark against Russia, got its debt cut roughly in half and restructured further, paying maybe 30 cents on the dollar. Liaquat thinks Gladstone believed repayment was moral and did not invade for profit, but says Egypt got a raw deal.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.