Why Benn Jordan can’t stop investigating Flock
Benn Jordan argues Flock's real problem is its warrantless, insecure private network, and that lasting fixes need local democratic action, transparency, audits and compromise rather than outrage or cameras-everywhere promises.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 5:02
You can't opt out of Flock, and you're paying for it through property taxes
Benn says the anger is about no choice. You can swap your phone's OS, turn off Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, or skip an Echo, but you can't “go to the grocery store without somebody tracking your vehicle.” Nobody voted on these cameras, and residents fund the surveillance themselves. It is like the NSA, only “much more local.”
- ▶ 7:06
Local democracy is working: Flock and data centers made people learn who their city council members are
Benn sees the backlash as democracy in action. People now show up to meetings, and in Asheville, North Carolina, surveillance policy may help bring in a new mayor. He cautions that Flock has become a buzzword. Politicians who attack it may still sign Axon or Motorola contracts, and Flock was simply the loudest and most defensive vendor.
- ▶ 10:09
Flock's defensive PR strategy backfired: digging in works for Donald Trump, not for most people
Benn guesses a publicist told Flock to repeat one message and dig in. Flock denied security vulnerabilities and redefined words, and people noticed. Axon and similar contractors stay out of the spotlight, and Benn suggests that is probably deliberate for any company courting tax dollars.
- ▶ 12:13
The Flock network, not the camera, is the problem: a warrantless nationwide 30-day location database
Older ALPRs, such as police-car mounts, were fine in Benn's view. Flock built a private network that lets any participating department search 30 days of vehicle movements nationwide without a warrant. Earlier sharing went through NCIC, which needs a magistrate's warrant. His analogy: having an officer log your car at every public camera for 30 days is “a serial killer situation” that would normally need a serious crime to justify it.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.