What Actually Makes a Good Creator Business
Colin and Samir pit eight creator products against each other and conclude that the best creator business, Crunch Labs, is one where the product and the content are the same thing.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 6:35
Creator products are entrepreneurship in reverse: the audience and the content engine come before the product
Samir says a normal founder builds a product and then hunts for customers. A creator already has an intimate relationship with a large audience and a system for making content. Feastables' chocolate-making video got 61 million views, which Samir calls a competitive advantage for a Mr. Beast. They add that Feastables works as world building: it is a character in Mr. Beast's world, even on other channels.
- ▶ 3:03
A niche creator's product may not be a business itself but a story engine that makes brand deals better
Looking at the $50 reusable Long Weekend camera, Samir argues it is not very scalable and works more like a community identifier, like a Press Publish hat. He sees it as a way to give creators a narrative and set up better brand deals, such as an Airbnb trip. Colin suggests it should centre on community and planned trips rather than the camera itself.
- ▶ 10:38
The best creator business is a lifestyle business: a die-hard audience plus a product that matches its enthusiasm
Sarah Renee Clark has 452,000 subscribers, and her color cube business does over five million dollars a year with a team of her, her husband and a handful of others. The cubes are a collect-them-all business, now on volume two. Samir calls this the business most creators should aspire to. Crunch Labs, by comparison, has 50-plus employees.
- ▶ 14:13
Crunch Labs shows the product can eventually fund the videos, and subscriptions make that stable
Colin says Mark Rober went from videos funding the product to the product funding the videos. Crunch Labs sold 100,000 boxes in six months and reached profitability. It shipped over two million build boxes in a year and a half, which at an assumed $27.50 average purchase is about $55 million. It is also a recurring subscription, which gives stable revenue.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.