Are you a better investor than a Fund I VC? | Zach Ruchman
Zach Ruchman explains how an allocator underwrites managers across fund generations, team formation and attribution, and argues that private markets reward real edge in picking and winning, which AI sourcing cannot supply.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 37:28
A first investment should be a bet on a multi-fund, 20-year partnership, not a 10-year trade
When Zach brings a fund to investment committee, the question is whether it could be a multifund partnership. If so, re-ups should be the default unless things change; otherwise it is “just a trade.” His re-up memo begins with everything that has changed since the last memo: strategy, fund size, return target, whether GPs sold a stake and lost carry motivation. He wants the P in GP/LP to stay partner.
- ▶ 40:01
Fund one tests whether a great investor can build a firm; fund four tests whether the builder is still a great investor
Zach assumes a spinout is a talented investor, but a fund one also demands fundraising, LP management and back office. Great investors are not always great firm builders. By fund four, the question reverses: with big AUM and fees, is the leader's finger still on the pulse? And do the investors driving value get enough carry? Misaligned carry can push talent out.
- ▶ 46:14
Attribution is murky, so check it with founder references, including off-sheet ones
Zach says an attribution spreadsheet never settles who really did a deal. He asks founders who they first met, who sat on the board, who added value, and whether they would do the deal again if the person spun out. On-sheet references are almost always glowing, so he also calls off-sheet ones and reads between the lines. He assigns mental percentages of credit.
- ▶ 53:53
The easiest fund one to underwrite is a team that lifts out together; the hardest is a brand-new team
Zach ranks fund ones. A team that lifts out together already has relationships, roles and a foundation. A solo GP is in the middle: they must either be a strong firm builder or stay a small boutique with outsourced help. A brand-new team is hardest, since you must underwrite each person and cannot see how they will gel. He would rather wait for fund two or three.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.