SpaceX has no competition — Saurav Shroff, Starpath
Saurav Shroff argues that orbital AI data centers need fully reusable rockets, SpaceX has no real competitor and won't sell launch, so Starpath is building capacity and may build its own launch company.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 0:00
The launch market is a misnomer: SpaceX won't sell Falcon 9 launch, and rivals are chasing yesterday's rocket
Saurav says there is one real launch company. SpaceX no longer sells traditional launch services. Roughly ten competitors are copying Falcon 9, and some sell rockets that don't exist yet. He calls it “the worst market of any kind” because it looked like supply was growing when none could be bought. Future demand will be about 99% AI data satellites and 1% telecom, and that demand needs fully reusable rockets.
- ▶ 5:08
Without competition, one company could own all superintelligence capacity, and game theory says no rocket owner will sell launch
Saurav says a rocket owner with demand far above supply and high margins has no rational reason to sell launch. Each company that builds a working reusable rocket would reason the same way and deploy its own data satellites. He sees two futures, one with competition and one with a single owner that has no reason to cut price or raise quality. He thinks competition is the probable one. It only takes two companies selling launch to change the dynamic.
- ▶ 7:39
Falcon 9 is 5x too expensive and 10x too small for orbital AI data centers
Saurav's math: a data satellite must cost about $5 per watt to beat the $10–15 per watt of a ground data center. That leaves about $1 per watt for launch. For a 1,000 kg, 200 kW satellite, launch must cost about $200 per kilogram. Falcon 9 sold at single-digit thousands per kilogram. Each launch carries roughly 2 MW, so 2 GW would take 1,000 launches. The fix is a rocket with both stages reusable. Only SpaceX and Stoke Space are seriously building one.
- ▶ 14:50
Starpath has a date in mind: if launch doesn't fix itself, it will build a launch company
Saurav says that if SpaceX doesn't re-enter the market, or multiple players don't bid large launch contracts at prices like $200–500 per kilogram, Starpath will build its own launch company. He says this is the first time he has said it on record. The reason is to make its customers successful and to keep superintelligence from being held by a couple of companies. He had not seen this as a problem three months earlier. A friend's questions changed his mind, and he opened a spreadsheet and started designing a rocket.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.