The first network effect was a phone call (ft. James Gleick)
James Gleick argues the telephone was shaped by its users, not its inventors, and that its network effects, monopoly and Bell Labs' freedom set the template for modern innovation.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 3:34
Treating the telephone as an improved telegraph was the founding mistake; it was a new species
James says Western Union's president called the first telephone patent offer a toy. The telegraph served businesses, needed trained operators and a code, and left a written record. The telephone was spontaneous and casual, and anyone could pick it up. Jokes and chatter survived on it. Edison even thought the phonograph would perfect the telephone by recording calls, but ephemerality was the point.
- ▶ 8:10
The telephone demonstrated the first network effect: one phone is useless, and Bell understood that
Philip Reis built a working device in Frankfurt and it sat for sale in a curiosity shop, but there was only one. James says nobody asked what you can do with one telephone. Bell, interested in speech and conversation, grasped that many telephones are needed. Phone companies later advertised that each new subscriber added value for all the others, so a network of 1,000 is more than 10 times as valuable as one of 100.
- ▶ 14:18
The telephone was defined by its users, not by the people who made and sold it
James says manufacturers kept being surprised by uses they couldn't stop. Isolated prairie farm wives and farmers strung their own lines on barbed wire, the devil's rope, and ran little networks with no switchboards. The same fence meant to wall land off connected people. Mark Twain mocked his wife's aimless phone chat, but James hears women cut off from one another suddenly sharing knowledge.
- ▶ 22:31
Bell's patent was shaky, but James doesn't think monopoly was required for the technology to spread
James calls the patent ridiculous: it was extended to cover anyone's telephone, and bribery of a drunk patent examiner was involved. He notes the technology spread across the country outside Bell's control in the 1880s and 90s, with rogue and independent companies working just as well. What was needed was coordination and linking into one national system. The consolidation by J. P. Morgan was a financial choice, not a technical necessity.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.