The man who fought Napster is now fighting AI | Decoder
Mitch Glazier of the RIAA argues that AI music fights are about preserving human art, so creators must first secure their rights, and fans, labeling and licensing can then shape the market.
Watch on YouTube ↗Charlie's summary
- ▶ 7:06
This time the music industry, fans and artists are on the same side, fighting to keep art human
Mitch contrasts AI with Napster, when fans stood against the labels. Now he says everyone is “rowing in the same general direction” to preserve the connection between a human artist and a fan. Copyright exists to give people an incentive to keep making art, and Mitch asks what happens to culture if music made in 2 seconds drowns out that incentive.
- ▶ 18:27
Fans will restore scarcity, but only if creators' basic rights are secured first
Mitch thinks fans always win in the end, because any service needs people to pay subscriptions. He expects fully machine-made music to stay suspect forever, while assistive AI may become as accepted as the synthesizer or autotune. The test is whether the human connection is maintained. Labeling drives consumer reactions, which drive the economics, but fans can only steer the market if creators' rights are secured.
- ▶ 25:07
A tiny 46-person RIAA fights trillion-dollar AI companies with music and artists as its leverage
Mitch says the RIAA handles content protection, takedowns, certifications and lobbying with 46 people and a three-person lobbying team. The whole US recorded music business was $11 billion wholesale last year, while one AI company has a $2 trillion market cap and super PACs spend $250 million in a cycle. What the industry has is music and artists people trust.
- ▶ 27:09
Mitch checks his gut against people who disagree, and changes course about 40% of the time
Mitch wants advisers who are not yes people. His gut reaction survives about 60% of the time, and 40% of the time he takes a different path. He also calls friends on the other side of the AI fight to learn what would make sense to a judge or policymaker. If you want a real solution rather than good trouble, you need a realistic landing zone.
Give your email to unlock the rest of the key points — for every episode.
Do more with Charlie
Free — sign in with your email, no password.